The examination states

The state judicial behavior committee dismissed a complaint against Pittsburgh Magistrat Xander Orenstein after a man whom the judge published for a deposit without cash was later charged in a fatal sting along the Montour trail.

The examination of Orenstein came at the urging of the state MP Valerie Gaydos (R-44), who shared the letter from the behavioral committee with the next generation newsroom.

In the letter dated February 14, it was found that the board of directors had rejected Gaydos's complaint after determining that the result of his investigation does not support a probable cause of judicial misconduct.

Orenstein, whose district serves parts of Lawreceville, Polish Hill, Bloomfield and Strip District, rejected a statement.

The lawyer, who uses pronouns, stood the widespread examination after Anthony Quessensen, a man whom they had released in 2023 against non -monetary deposit in October when Benjamin Brallier (44) fatal, a triggered state police, the police explocoral development representative.

Orenstein published Quessensen, 25, in June 2023 because of simple assault and robbery after being accused of trying to snap a man's phone in the city center of Pittsburgh.

The judge of Allegheny County Common Pleas, Susan Evashavik, Dilucente, pulled Orenstein at the end of April 2024 from the hearing of charges after a separate decision without a rocket for a suspect who was accused of leading the state police to high -speed hunting.

Orenstein still does not hear any charges, said Joseph Asturi, director of government matters and media relationships in the fifth court.

An indictment is a hearing in which a defendant is officially charged with a crime.

The death of Brallier triggered claims for the resignation or the elevation of Orenstein by angry officials, although some defended the decision as the standard. The New York state police later identified Quessens as a person of interest in a New York knife stab, which took place on a path in men.

Quesen is located in the Allegheny County prison and is not entitled to deposit. A preliminary hearing in Brallier's death is planned for April.

Orenstein, who was elected in 2021, ran on a platform to make the judicial system of merciful and fairer. Orenstein said she had previously worked as a bank scientist.

“Ultimately, the judges have a lot of discretion, and I don't think we want to change that,” said Gaydos. “But in this case this person does not have to be elected in my opinion.”

It is rare that elected judges are charged, and in the letter from the Board of Directors it states that the decision is finally with “not an appeal process for reviewing the hiring of an submitted complaint by the Board of Directors”.

For gaydos, this means the only plausible way to displace Orenstein, the next choice.

“That is why we have elections if we do not agree to the judge's discretion,” said Gaydos. “If there was no judicial misconduct, the ultimate is that people have to vote [them] out of.”

The next election for Orenstein's judicial district is 2027.

Abigail Hakas is a reporter for the next generation newsroom, part of the Center for Media Innovation at Point Park University. Reach them abigail.hakas@pointpark.edu.

NGN is a regional intelligence service that focuses on reporting on the government and business reporting in the southwest of Pennsylvania. You can find more information about foundation and corporate supporters Here.